Your team has agreed to leave ADP, but the first planning meeting stalls on a basic question: which ADP product are you actually leaving?
Moving from Workforce Now into a PEO is different from replacing TotalSource, and that distinction changes how you review your agreement and plan the cutover.
If the switch already feels more complicated than expected, this guide will help you identify your current setup and work through the migration in the right order.
By the time you reach your first Justworks payroll, the responsibilities on both sides should be clear.
Why Move From ADP to Justworks?
For many growing companies, moving from ADP to Justworks comes down to simplifying administration, clarifying costs, and getting more support as the team grows.
Change the Federal Payroll Tax Relationship
With an ADP payroll platform such as Workforce Now, ADP generally processes filings as a service provider while your company remains responsible for its employment taxes. Justworks is a certified PEO that assumes responsibility for federal employment taxes on wages it processes under the CPEO arrangement.
Want to learn more about Justworks?
Move Benefits Into a PEO Arrangement
Justworks can bring health plan administration and workers’ compensation into its PEO offering. Medical administration is included in PEO Plus rather than PEO Basic, so companies moving for health benefits should compare the Plus plan with their current total cost.
Start With Published Pricing
ADP does not publish standard pricing for Workforce Now or TotalSource, while Justworks lists per-employee prices for its PEO plans. Published pricing does not reveal the complete cost, but it gives your team a clearer starting point before requesting a proposal.
Your company still manages its employees and makes its normal workplace decisions under co-employment. What changes is how selected administrative responsibilities are handled behind the scenes.
How to Migrate From ADP to Justworks
Here’s how to plan your move from ADP to Justworks and keep the cutover on track.
1. Confirm Which ADP Product You Are Actually On
Start by determining whether you use an ADP payroll platform or ADP TotalSource.
ADP positions RUN Powered by ADP for companies with 1–49 employees and ADP Workforce Now for companies with 50 or more employees. ADP TotalSource, meanwhile, is a PEO that establishes a co-employment relationship.
If you use TotalSource, you are moving from one PEO to another. If you use RUN, Workforce Now, or another ADP payroll arrangement without TotalSource, you are moving from a payroll or HCM provider into a PEO relationship.
Review your service agreement and product name first. Your W-2 filer information and available tax documents can provide additional clues, but they should not be your only test because PEO tax reporting can vary by state.
2. Read Your Service Agreement for Term and Notice
Check your agreement before choosing a migration date.
ADP RUN currently does not require a long-term contract and can be terminated at any time, but you should not assume the same terms apply to Workforce Now, TotalSource, or a customized ADP arrangement.
Identify your renewal date, notice requirement, auto-renewal language, early-termination provision, and any responsibilities ADP retains after the final payroll.
Justworks also recommends reviewing cancellation terms before notifying an existing provider and working backward from the first planned payroll on the new system.
3. Pick the Cutover Date
Expedited enrollment can take two to three weeks, while the typical PEO onboarding timeline is three to six weeks, depending largely on how quickly the company completes its application.
Justworks recommends switching at the beginning of a quarter or calendar year when possible because it can make tax reporting cleaner. A midyear transition is still possible, but leave enough time for benefits enrollment, payroll-data collection, state-account review, and testing.
4. Pull Year-to-Date Payroll Data From ADP
Justworks requires a year-to-date payroll report as part of PEO onboarding.
For ADP customers, Justworks specifically says to look for the Master Control Report, with Column Y typically containing year-to-date taxable wages.
Make sure the report includes:
- Each employee’s state of work
- Year-to-date taxable wages
- Social Security, Medicare, and unemployment withholdings
- Earnings from January 1 through the Justworks start date
- Anyone paid earlier in the year, including former employees
The report may be submitted as a PDF, CSV, or Excel file.
Without accurate YTD data, the company may be taxed more than necessary and may not be able to recover the overpaid employer taxes, although affected employees may still be able to recover their overpayments when filing their personal returns.
5. Export Everything Else and Confirm How Long Access Lasts
Before closing the ADP account, download the payroll and employee records you may need after migration.
These should include payroll registers, available quarterly tax filings or reference reports, state returns, W-2 archives, employee records, benefits deductions, contribution history, garnishments, PTO balances, and payment confirmations.
Justworks recommends asking how long records will remain accessible after cancellation, since access policies can differ between providers and arrangements. Ask your ADP representative to confirm the access window and available export formats in writing.
If you are leaving TotalSource, ask which company-level tax reports will remain available rather than assuming you can download standalone Forms 940 and 941 filed under your company’s EIN.
6. Map State Tax Accounts State by State
Justworks divides state unemployment insurance reporting into three categories:
- PEO-reporting states: Justworks reports in aggregate under its EIN and SUI account. Existing company accounts in these states generally need to be closed to prevent delinquency notices and fines.
- Client-reporting states: Filing remains connected to an account tied to your company’s EIN. Justworks may collect your existing account number and rate or register an account on your behalf.
- Hybrid states: Justworks registers an individual unemployment account associated with its master account, and an existing account may need to be closed using its instructions.
Review every state separately during onboarding. Do not close existing withholding accounts until the previous provider has completed its final quarterly and annual filings and Justworks confirms which accounts it will take over.
7. Set the Waiting Period Carefully
Justworks offers 0-day, 30-day, and 60 day health insurance waiting periods. These can only be set during initial company onboarding or a health insurance renewal.
Review how the selected period will affect both current employees and future hires before finalizing it. Once an employee meets the applicable waiting period, coverage generally becomes effective on the first of the month following the employee’s eligibility date.
8. Submit the Census and Account for COBRA Participants
If you are applying for health insurance through Justworks, you must provide an employee and dependent census so the company can receive plan and pricing options.
Existing COBRA participants do not automatically disqualify the company, but no more than 10% of employees may be on its COBRA policies.
Companies then have 45 days from the Justworks benefits effective date to provide the information required to transfer those participants. Count the COBRA population before enrollment and raise any concerns with the onboarding team early.
9. Sequence Provider and Coverage Cancellations Precisely
Wait until Justworks confirms the relevant start and coverage dates before terminating anything. According to the Justworks PEO onboarding guide:
- The current payroll provider should end the day before the Justworks PEO start date.
- Existing health insurance should end the day before the new Justworks benefits become effective.
- The previous workers’ compensation policy should end on the Justworks PEO start date.
Do not assume the benefits’ effective date and PEO start date are always the same. Use the dates confirmed by the onboarding team and obtain written cancellation confirmations from ADP, your broker, and the applicable carriers.
Workers’ compensation is generally required as part of Justworks PEO. Justworks warns that keeping another workers’ compensation policy can result in being charged for both policies, except in limited approved situations.
10. Sign IRS Form 8973
On or after the company’s start date, Justworks will prompt you to electronically sign IRS Form 8973 within 10 business days.
The form notifies the IRS that a service contract between a CPEO and a customer has started and identifies the forms the CPEO will file for wages processed through it.
Justworks states that signing Form 8973 is necessary for the customer to benefit from its CPEO status and avoid joint federal payroll-tax liability for those wages.
11. Reconcile the First Payroll and Brief Employees on Two W-2s
Before the first Justworks payroll is processed, compare the employee setup, gross wages, deductions, employer taxes, benefits deductions, and expected net pay against your final ADP payroll.
Account for any change in payroll frequency when reviewing the results, then resolve discrepancies with the Justworks onboarding team.
Employees should also be told that a midyear switch results in two W-2s: one from the previous provider for the first part of the year and another from Justworks for the wages it processed afterward. Employees will need both when filing their taxes.
ADP to Justworks Implementation Checklist
Use this as a quick status check. Refer to the roadmap above when you need the details behind an item.
Planning
Make sure the scope and timing have been settled.
- ADP product and exit requirements confirmed
- Migration owner assigned
- Justworks plan and start date approved
Account Setup
Check that the decisions affecting payroll and coverage are complete.
- Banking and payroll settings verified
- Benefits waiting period and effective date confirmed
- Active garnishments submitted
- State tax account actions documented
Data Readiness
Confirm that Justworks has the records needed for an accurate launch.
- Complete YTD payroll report submitted
- Former employees included in YTD data
- Employee census submitted and COBRA participants identified
- Required ADP records exported
Go Live
Run through the final checks before closing the migration.
- Employees briefed on enrollment and W-2 changes
- Final ADP payroll and service end date confirmed
- Benefits and workers’ compensation cancellations confirmed
- Form 8973 signed
- First Justworks payroll reconciled
- State account follow up completed
- ACA reporting responsibility assigned
- Final confirmations saved
What Success Looks Like
A successful transition becomes clear after your first two payroll cycles with Justworks.
Employees are being paid correctly, and any discrepancies found during testing or the first live run have been resolved.
Everyone who enrolled in benefits also has a confirmed effective date, with no gap caused by the switch. Your previous payroll service and insurance policies have ended on the correct dates without duplicate charges.
Behind the scenes, your ADP records are safely archived and each state account has a documented status.
Form 8973 is complete as well.
Employees know where to find their new information and what to expect at tax time, while your HR and finance teams can manage the new setup without chasing missing records from ADP.
Moving From ADP to Justworks Best Practices
Once the basic roadmap is in place, these are the areas that deserve a closer look.
Compare the Full Cost
Justworks’ published per employee price is a starting point, not the final cost.
Compare it with your complete ADP setup and account for benefit premiums or broker costs that may change. This gives your team a more realistic view of the financial impact.
Incomplete YTD Payroll Data
Missing or inaccurate figures in the Master Control Report can affect payroll tax calculations after the move. Former employees are especially easy to overlook during a midyear migration.
Request the report early and reconcile it against your final ADP payroll before Justworks begins processing wages.
Different Requirements Across States
State unemployment accounts cannot all be handled the same way.
Closing an account too early could interfere with ADP’s final filings, while leaving the wrong account open may lead to notices.
Track the required action for each state separately and wait for confirmation before making changes.
Preserve Your ADP Records
ADP does not publish one standard access period for former customers. Export the records you may need before the service ends and confirm any remaining access in writing.
Justworks reporting begins on your start date, so it will not rebuild your earlier ADP history.
Misaligned Coverage Dates
Health coverage and workers’ compensation should not automatically be cancelled on the same date.
End the old health plan the day before the new coverage becomes effective, while the previous workers’ compensation policy should end on the Justworks start date.
Confirm both cancellations in writing to avoid a coverage gap or overlapping charges.
Final Thoughts
Before presenting a recommendation to your controller or leadership team, compare the full cost of your ADP setup with Justworks at your current headcount.
Use your employee census and benefits invoice to keep that comparison grounded in what your company actually pays. If Justworks still looks like the better fit, explore its PEO offering and confirm the proposed timeline with its team.
We hope this guide helps you make a confident decision, and once you’re ready for the migration, head to Justworks’ website to get started.
FAQs
How Long Does a Move From ADP to Justworks Take?
Timing varies because approval and your ADP exit requirements affect the schedule.
Will Employees Get Two W-2s?
Yes. During a midyear switch, employees receive one W-2 from ADP and another from Justworks for the wages each provider processed.
Will There Be a Gap in Health Coverage or Workers’ Compensation?
A gap can be avoided by following the confirmed effective dates. Cancel the old health plan the day before the new coverage begins and end the previous workers’ compensation policy on the Justworks start date.
What Happens to ACA Reporting in The Transition Year?
A company is generally an applicable large employer if it averaged at least 50 full time employees, including full time equivalents, during the previous year. Justworks can handle Forms 1094-C and 1095-C when it receives adequate coverage information, so confirm what it needs for the months before your start date.
Can We Keep Our Existing Broker or Health Plan?
Possibly. PEO Basic customers may offer external health insurance, and Justworks says it can work with licensed brokers. Companies using Justworks PEO health plans cannot also offer outside coverage to employees or dependents covered by those plans.




