Beyond Corporate Astrology: The Science and Strategy of Personality Assessments in Hiring

If you’ve ever sat through a personality test during hiring and thought, “This feels a bit like corporate astrology”—you’re not wrong. In this episode, I talk with Jason Hreha, Founder & CEO of Persona, about why so many workplace assessments are built on outdated theories and questionable science, and how to separate the gimmicks from the tools that actually help you hire better. We dig into what reliability and predictive validity really mean, why they’re non-negotiables for any credible test, and where most HR teams go wrong in applying behavioral science to talent decisions.

Jason also shares his work on a new leadership-focused assessment that aims to measure two very different—but equally valuable—leadership archetypes: transformational and operational. From structuring interviews to making personality data a meaningful (but not overblown) part of your hiring process, this conversation is a crash course in evidence-based talent evaluation.

What You’ll Learn

  • The two core metrics that determine whether a personality test is scientifically valid.
  • Why many popular assessments (hello, Myers-Briggs) fail at predicting job performance.
  • How to use psychometric tools strategically in hiring—without over-relying on them.
  • The difference between transformational and operational leadership styles.
  • Why getting crystal clear on behaviors is the key to evaluating talent effectively.

Key Takeaways

  • Start with science, not vibes. If a test can’t demonstrate strong reliability and predictive validity, it shouldn’t drive hiring decisions.
  • Structure beats gut feel. Consistent interview questions and standardized assessments make candidate comparisons far more accurate.
  • Use personality data as one piece of the puzzle. Around 25% weight in decision-making is reasonable—cognitive ability and interpersonal fit still matter more.
  • Match leadership style to the challenge. Operational leaders thrive in scaling and refining systems; transformational leaders excel at creating something entirely new.
  • Define the work in behavioral terms. List the exact actions a new hire must take before deciding what to measure and how to measure it.

Chapters

  • [00:00] Why so many workplace assessments fail basic science
  • [02:45] Reliability vs. predictive validity explained
  • [06:40] How much personality tests should weigh in hiring decisions
  • [08:33] Using assessments to compare candidates fairly
  • [11:51] Leadership testing: transformational vs. operational leaders
  • [17:21] Can AI replace psychometric assessments?
  • [18:44] The most common mistake in applying behavioral science to hiring
  • [22:21] Where to find Jason’s work and research
  • [23:35] David’s perspective on personality tests

Meet Our Guest

photo of Jason Hreha

Jason Hreha is the co-founder and CEO of Persona, a talent-as-a-service company that leverages behavioral science—drawing on his nearly 15 years of expertise—to revolutionize how remote assistant talent is matched and deployed. Formerly Global Head of Behavioral Science at Walmart, he spearheaded behavioral strategy initiatives and also founded startups like Kite.io and Dopamine. A Stanford graduate in Human Biology (neuroscience), Jason remains a prominent thought leader in applied behavioral science, frequently advising companies and speaking on the intersection of psychology and product design.

You may also like