How to Write a Payroll Services RFP for Outsourcing

Consider creating an RFP when:

• Managing a multinational workforce across different tax jurisdictions
• Ensuring payroll services integrate with HR, time tracking, or benefits platforms
• Operating in a highly regulated industry with strict compliance needs
• Handling diverse pay structures, such as contractors and hourly employees
• Needing specialized payroll services, such as global pay or unionized workforce support

When an RFP Might be Overkill

If your company is small or your payroll is straightforward (e.g., under 20 employees with simple pay cycles), a full RFP might be unnecessary. In these cases, it’s often faster to contact payroll service providers directly, review their packages, and select a plan that meets your needs. Save the RFP process for situations where complexity, compliance, or scale requires a detailed evaluation.

If you think your needs are straightforward and can skip the RFP process, below are my recommendations for the best payroll service providers. 

Drowning in RFP drafting? Let us help.

Sit down with an expert to get help creating your RFP, for free.

Talk To An Expert

Top Payroll Services to Consider

Here’s my list of the top 10 payroll services available, to help you get started in your search:

1. 1. Deel — Best for global teams
2. 2. RemoFirst — Best for managing international payments
3. 3. Worksuite — Best for global contractors and freelancers
4. 4. OnPay — Best for industry-specific payroll
5. 5. Patriot Payroll — Best for US-based businesses
6. 6. Paycom — Best for real-time pay previews
7. 7. Neeyamo — Best for remote global onboarding
8. 8. Reliable Payroll Services — Best for personalized support
9. 9. ADP — Best for union payroll and garnishments
10. 10. HSP Group — Best for scaling internationally

Show More (5)

RFI vs RFP vs RFQ: What’s the Difference?

Knowing the differences between an RFI, RFP, and RFQ helps you choose the right approach when outsourcing payroll. An RFI is best when you’re exploring payroll service models. An RFP is essential when you have complex requirements and need to evaluate providers thoroughly. An RFQ works well when you already know the exact payroll services you want and just need pricing details.

Choosing the right document for your procurement process is crucial to reducing friction and ensuring efficiency:

Document Type	Purpose	When to Use	What to Include	Level of Detail Required
Request for Information (RFI)	Gather general information about payroll services	When exploring options without specific requirements	Company background, service offerings	Low
Request for Proposal (RFP)	Solicit detailed proposals for complex payroll needs	When you need comprehensive solutions and comparisons	Detailed requirements, evaluation criteria	High
Request for Quotation (RFQ)	Request price quotes for specific payroll services	When you have clear specifications and need pricing	Exact specifications, quantity, delivery terms	Medium

Common RFP Mistakes to Avoid

Rushing through an RFP or skipping key details can lead to confusion, wasted time, or ending up with poor-fit vendors. When your team is deciding on a payroll service, it's important to avoid common pitfalls that can complicate the selection process. 

By steering clear of these mistakes, you'll create a smoother path to finding the right vendor:

Insufficient Background or Context

When you don't provide enough background or context, vendors can't tailor their proposals to your specific needs. For example, without providing your payroll volume, employee locations, or pay frequencies, vendors can’t tailor their proposals, leading to generic responses that don't address your specific issues. 

Provide specific payroll data upfront so the pricing and service scope you receive are accurate. You should also include your company's goals, challenges, and any relevant history to give vendors a complete picture of your business.

Missing or Unclear Budget

If you don't specify a budget or are vague about your financial constraints, you might receive proposals that don't align with what you can afford. Sharing your budget range helps vendors propose realistic solutions.

Payroll service pricing models vary (per employee, per pay run, or bundled fees), so it’s also important to inform yourself and set realistic expectations around pricing too.

Vague Requirements or Legal Jargon

Vague requirements or excessive legal jargon can confuse vendors, resulting in proposals that miss the mark. 

Use straightforward language and clearly define what you need. For instance, specify the number of employees, payroll frequency, and any integration needs to avoid misunderstandings.

No Evaluation Criteria Shared

Without sharing evaluation criteria, payroll vendors won't know what you're prioritizing, leading to mismatched proposals. 

Clearly outline how you'll assess their offerings, whether it's cost, features, or support. This transparency helps vendors focus on what's important to you and ensures you get relevant proposals.

No Standard Format for Vendor Responses

If you don't provide a standardized template for vendor responses, comparing proposals becomes a headache. 

Provide a template or outline for responses, so vendors know exactly what to include. This makes it easier for your team to evaluate and compare proposals side by side without extra work.

Assemble Your Payroll Services RFP Team

Building a payroll services RFP is a collaborative effort. The strongest RFPs reflect the perspectives of leadership, payroll experts, and day-to-day users, reducing risk and ensuring the document captures all business requirements. Involving the right stakeholders from the start keeps the process efficient and aligned with organizational goals. 

Here’s who to involve and why:

Project Sponsor

The project sponsor is typically an executive who champions the RFP process and ensures it aligns with the organization's strategic goals. They provide oversight, approve budgets, and remove obstacles that might impede progress. In a payroll services RFP, this could be your CFO or Head of HR.

Functional Experts

Functional experts bring specialized knowledge about payroll processes and systems, ensuring the RFP addresses technical and operational needs. They help identify essential requirements, such as accurate tax filings, reporting obligations, and integration with HR or time-tracking systems. This group often includes payroll managers, compliance officers, or HR and payroll specialists.

Procurement or RFP Writers

Procurement professionals or RFP writers ensure the document is clear, well-structured, and aligned with procurement policies. They help articulate expectations around service delivery, compliance, and pricing in a way that makes it easy for vendors to respond effectively.

End Users and Stakeholders

End users and stakeholders provide practical insights into the day-to-day needs and challenges of using payroll services. Their input ensures the RFP addresses real-world concerns and usability needs for both administrators and employees (e.g., self-service portals, mobile access). This group could include HR staff, finance team members, and employee representatives who interact with payroll systems regularly.

Define Must-Haves & Goals

Before you send out a payroll services RFP, align internally on what your organization truly needs from a provider, and why. By identifying pain points, setting goals, and clarifying non-negotiables, you’ll help vendors craft accurate proposals and make it easier for your team to evaluate responses. 

Consider these factors:

• Challenges with current payroll setup: Identify what's not working today. Is payroll processing too slow? Are you dealing with tax filing errors, compliance penalties, or late payments? Knowing your pain points helps vendors demonstrate how their services will solve them.
• Desired improvements and success metrics: What improvements are you after? Define what success looks like — e.g., faster payroll cycles, error-free compliance reporting, or better employee access through self-service portals. This ensures vendors propose outcomes that align with your goals.
• Service scope and compliance needs: Outline the exact services you expect (e.g., end-to-end payroll processing, global payroll, handling unionized staff) and specify compliance requirements, such as GDPR or local labor laws. Make sure vendors know what's non-negotiable.
• User roles and access: Who will use the system and how? Consider the different roles, from HR staff to managers, and ensure the solution fits their needs and workflows. For example, HR and finance staff may need detailed payroll reports, while employees may require mobile access to pay stubs or year-end forms.
• Service delivery model: Decide if you want fully outsourced payroll, co-managed payroll (where some processes stay in-house), or a hybrid model. This helps vendors align their proposals with your preferred approach.

Write the Payroll Services RFP

Now it’s time to assemble your payroll services RFP into a clear, structured document. A well-organized RFP makes it easier for vendors to respond accurately and for your team to evaluate proposals fairly. By following a structured approach, you’ll ensure every detail is covered and that providers understand your expectations.

Here’s what to include:

1. Executive Summary

Provide a brief overview of your organization's needs, challenges, and goals for the payroll services. For example, reducing compliance risks, simplifying international payroll, or improving employee self-service. 

This section sets the stage for vendors by highlighting key objectives and what you aim to achieve with this procurement. Keep it concise but informative. Focus on giving vendors a high-level understanding of why you’re outsourcing payroll and what success looks like.

2. Scope of Work

Detail the specific tasks and services you expect the vendor to perform. Clearly outline the breadth of the project, including any unique requirements or constraints. This may include payroll processing, tax filings, direct deposit management, year-end reporting, employee portal access, or multi-currency payroll. 

Be clear about volume (e.g., number of employees, pay frequency) and any unique requirements, such as handling contractors or unionized staff. This helps vendors understand the full extent of what’s required and allows them to propose solutions that fit your specific needs.

3. Technical Requirements

List the technical specifications and integrations you’ll need with HRIS, benefits administration, or time-tracking systems, and specify what kind of reporting you expect (e.g., compliance reports, payroll summaries, employee access to pay stubs). This ensures providers can confirm compatibility and meet your transparency needs.

Being clear about these needs prevents misunderstandings and ensures compatibility with your current infrastructure.

4. Vendor Qualifications

Specify the qualifications and experience you expect from potential vendors. Ask for details about their industry experience, past projects, and team expertise. You should also request client references, case studies, and compliance certifications to verify credibility.

Reviewing this information will help you assess whether they have the capability and track record to deliver the payroll operations you need.

5. Security and Compliance Needs

Payroll data is highly sensitive. Outline your expectations for data security, storage, and compliance with relevant regulations (e.g., GDPR, HIPAA, SOC 2). 

Ask vendors to explain how they handle regulatory updates and audits. This ensures vendors understand the importance of safeguarding your data.

6. Onboarding and Ongoing Support

Instead of “training,” emphasize your expectations around onboarding assistance and long-term support. Specify timelines for implementation, the level of account management you expect, and what support channels will be available for both your human resources team and employees. 

Clear expectations here help payroll providers schedule their resources and timelines accordingly.

7. Pricing and Service Fees

Request transparent pricing, including per-employee or per-pay-run costs, setup fees, and any optional add-ons or potential hidden costs. Ask vendors to clearly outline billing models so you can streamline your comparison process.

Make it clear how you want this information presented, whether as a total cost or broken down by component. This transparency allows you to compare proposals fairly and avoid hidden fees.

8. Contract Terms

Define the length of contract you’re comfortable with, renewal and termination options, and any SLAs (service-level agreements) you require for payroll accuracy, compliance guarantees, or response times. Mention any specific terms that are non-negotiable for your organization. 

Providing this information upfront in your payroll RFP helps vendors understand the legal framework they’ll be working within.

9. Submission Instructions

Clearly explain how proposals should be submitted — including deadlines, file formats, and whether a specific RFP template must be used. A standard format makes evaluation easier and ensures nothing is overlooked.

Want help creating your RFP?

Let us handle the first draft, for free.

1. Share your requirements
2. Align budget and timeline
3. Receive RFP draft
4. Get ongoing support

Share Your Requirements

Define Your Evaluation Criteria

Clearly defined evaluation criteria keep your payroll services RFP process fair, transparent, and aligned with business goals. Establishing these benchmarks before reviewing proposals helps eliminate bias and ensures your team is evaluating vendors consistently. 

Here’s how to define your evaluation criteria:

What Matters Most?

Focus on what really counts by choosing 3–5 weighted categories that align with your goals and priorities. This keeps the evaluation process straightforward and targeted. 

Common RFP scoring categories for payroll services might include:

• Cost and pricing transparency
• Service scope and compliance expertise
• Vendor reputation and experience in your industry/regions
• Implementation and onboarding timeline
• Quality of customer and employee support (e.g., dedicated account manager, 24/7 help desk)

Use a Scoring Matrix

A scoring matrix helps you weigh each criterion according to its importance. For example, if cost is your top priority, assign it a higher weight than other factors. Use a 1–5 or 1–10 scale to score each criterion, allowing you to quantify how well each proposal meets your needs. Adjust the weightings to reflect your team’s internal priorities.

Clarify Your Scoring Process

Define who will score the proposals and how they’ll do it. Use a standardized rubric to ensure consistency and fairness. Hold a kickoff meeting to align reviewers on the criteria, priorities, and process before scoring begins, so everyone understands the expectations and approach. This ensures a smooth evaluation process and minimizes discrepancies or disputes later.

Issue the Payroll Services RFP

Sending out your payroll services RFP is more than just distribution — it’s about setting vendors up for success so they can provide accurate, detailed proposals. A clear process ensures providers understand your expectations, which improves the quality of responses you receive. 

Here’s how to handle this step:

Choose the Right Distribution Method

Distribute your RFP document in a way that ensures all potential providers can access it easily. This could include direct email, procurement portals, or RFP management software. 

Using a centralized system to track responses helps keep everything organized. Consider including a vendor contact list or using a role-based inbox to clarify communication channels.

Set Clear Timeline Expectations

A well-defined timeline helps vendors plan their responses and ensures a smooth process. At a minimum, share this timeline in the RFP itself:

• RFP release date
• Vendor Q&A period (for clarifying requirements)
• Final submission deadline
• Evaluation and selection period

This clarity helps vendors understand deadlines and allocate resources so they can prepare thorough proposals without rushing. 

Define Submission Requirements

Outline exactly how vendors should submit their proposals. Specify acceptable formats (PDF, Word documents, or Excel templates), whether they should follow a response template, and how to deliver (e.g., via upload portal or dedicated email). 

You should also clarify policies around late submissions. This avoids confusion, ensures consistent, comparable proposals, and keeps vendors on track.

Evaluate Responses & Shortlist Vendors

This is where all your preparation pays off — your team reviews vendor proposals and develops a shortlist with confidence. To keep the process objective and efficient, follow a structured approach that ensures fairness and transparency. 

Here’s how to evaluate payroll service providers:

• Organize proposals for review: Standardize the way proposals are shared internally. Create summary sheets that highlight each provider’s pricing model, service scope, compliance capabilities, and customer support approach. This makes side-by-side comparisons easier.
• Apply your scoring matrix: Use the scoring criteria you established earlier to evaluate each vendor. For example, a provider may score high on compliance expertise but lower on pricing flexibility. Quantifying responses helps remove subjectivity.
• Schedule presentations or service walk-throughs: Invite top providers to present their service model, onboarding process, and customer support systems. This gives you firsthand insight into how they operate and whether their services match what they promised on paper.
• Check references: Speak with current or former clients to validate vendor claims. Ask specifically about reliability, responsiveness, compliance support, and payroll accuracy. Would they recommend the provider again?
• Clarify proposal details: Don’t leave unanswered questions. Reach out to vendors for clarification on unclear points, such as fee structures or support response times. This ensures you make decisions based on complete and accurate information.

Select & Notify Vendors

Once your team selects a payroll services provider, the final steps are just as important as the evaluation itself. Clear communication, structured negotiations, and internal alignment will set the stage for a smooth partnership. 

Here’s how to wrap up the process:

Notify Selected and Unselected Vendors

Communicate promptly and respectfully with all providers. Notify your chosen vendor with enthusiasm, outlining next steps in the contracting process. For unselected vendors, send a professional thank-you and, if possible, provide high-level feedback. This keeps relationships positive for future opportunities.

Prepare for Final Negotiations

Expect to negotiate service fees, contract terms, and service-level agreements (SLAs) covering payroll accuracy, compliance guarantees, and customer support responsiveness. Come prepared with your must-haves and walk-away points, and use a structured agenda to keep discussions focused and efficient.

Ensure Internal Alignment Before Signing

Secure approvals from leadership, finance, and legal teams before finalizing. Provide a summary of why this vendor was chosen — highlighting compliance expertise, pricing model, and support — so decision-makers can approve quickly. This step avoids last-minute delays and ensures everyone is aligned.

What’s Next:

If you're in the process of researching payroll services, connect with a SoftwareSelect advisor for free recommendations.

You’ll fill out a form and have a quick chat where they get into the specifics of your needs. Then you'll get a shortlist of software to review. They'll even support you through the entire buying process, including price negotiations.