Recruitment Analytics: Complete Guide 2024
Recruitment can be frustrating, right? You spend a lot of energy finding great candidates only for them to slip away somewhere along the hiring process.
Exasperated, you question, “How can we stop this from happening?”.
This is where recruitment analytics can be used to help optimize the recruitment process and hire better candidates more efficiently.
What Is Recruitment Analytics?
Recruitment analytics refers to using data and analytical techniques to improve the hiring process. It involves collecting, analyzing, and interpreting data related to recruitment activities to make informed decisions, enhance efficiency, and achieve better outcomes in talent acquisition.
8 Reasons Recruitment Analytics Is Important
Someone once said “In God we trust, everyone else brings data”, which nicely summarizes the essence of why recruitment analytics is essential. Getting more granular, recruitment analytics is important for:
1. Enhanced decision-making
- Data-driven insights: Recruitment analytics is the basis of data-driven recruitment, providing objective data and insights that help recruiting teams make more informed decisions regarding their recruitment strategies and hiring planning.
2. Improved hiring quality
- Identifying top talent: Analytics helps identify which sources and methods yield the highest quality candidates, resulting in better hires more efficiently.
- Quality of hire: By analyzing the performance and retention data of new hires, orgz can refine its criteria and processes to consistently attract high-quality candidates.
3. Increased efficiency
- Reduced Time-to-Hire: Analyzing the recruitment funnel can identify bottlenecks and inefficiencies, allowing for streamlined operations and faster hiring cycles.
- Cost reduction: By optimizing sourcing channels and improving process efficiency, recruitment analytics can significantly reduce cost-per-hire. For example, by measuring the performance of job ads and success of non-paid job ad placements, you can fine tune your SEO strategy for recruiting and attract more candidates organically.
4. Better candidate experience
- Improved processes: Analytics can highlight areas where candidates are disengaging or facing difficulties, leading to improvements in the candidate journey and overall candidate experience.
- Enhanced engagement: Understanding candidate preferences and behaviors helps in tailoring communication and engagement strategies, leading to a better overall experience.
5. Strategic workforce planning
- Talent pipeline management: Analytics provides insights into the availability of talent and helps in building and maintaining a strong pipeline for future needs.
- Alignment with business goals: By understanding the talent landscape and aligning recruitment efforts with organizational goals, HR can better support business growth and success.
6. Diversity
- Tracking diversity metrics: Analytics helps track diversity metrics such as diversity of the talent pool and if certain teams hire more diverse candidates than others.
- Bias reduction: Recruitment analytics can help identify biases in the hiring process and suggest measures to mitigate them e.g. is the organization only hiring a certain candidate profile?
7. Achieve higher retention rates
- Candidate feedback: Analyzing candidate feedback can provide insights that organizations can use to improve the experience of existing employees and improve engagement and retention.
8. Continuous improvement
- Ongoing optimization: Recruitment analytics supports a culture of continuous improvement by serving as the fuel for recruitment audits and regularly measuring and analyzing key performance indicators (KPIs) and making data-driven adjustments.
- Benchmarking: Organizations can benchmark their performance against themselves as well as industry standards and best practices, identifying areas for improvement and staying competitive.
Key Metrics In Recruitment Analytics
So now you know the why, how about the what? Here are some key recruitment analytics metrics:
1. Time to Hire
Description: The average number of days taken from when a job opening is posted to when a candidate accepts the job offer.
Example: If a company posts a job on January 1st and a candidate accepts the offer on January 20th, the time to hire is 20 days.
2. Cost per Hire
Description: The total expense incurred to fill a position, including advertising, agency fees, and onboarding costs.
Example: If a company spends $3,000 on advertising, $2,000 on agency fees, and $500 in personnel hours, the cost per hire is $5,500.
3. Quality of hire
Description: A measure of how well new hires perform and fit within the company, typically assessed through performance reviews and retention rates.
Example: If a new hire consistently receives high performance ratings and remains with the company for more than a year, this indicates high hiring quality.
4. Sourcing channel efficiency
Description: This measures the effectiveness of different candidate sourcing methods such as LinkedIn, referral programs, or external partners.
Example: If 50 candidates are sourced from a job board and 10 are hired, the sourcing channel efficiency for that job board is a healthy 20%.
5. Applicant to hire ratio
Description: The ratio of the number of applicants for a position to the number of hires made for that position.
Example: If 100 candidates apply for a job and 5 are hired, the applicant-to-hire ratio is 20:1.
6. Offer acceptance rate
Description: The percentage of job offers extended by a company that is accepted by candidates.
Example: If a company extends 10 job offers and 8 are accepted, the offer acceptance rate is a healthy 80% (but 90% is better!)
7. First-year retention
Description: The percentage of new hires who remain with the company for a specified period, typically one year. Again, this helps indicate the quality of candidates being hired.
Example: If 50 new employees are hired and 45 are still with the company after one year, the retention rate is 90%.
Recruitment Analytics Levels
It’s helpful to categorize recruitment analytics into different levels based on the complexity and depth of analysis.
These levels help organizations understand how advanced they are regarding their use of data and analytics in recruitment, and what steps they can take to advance their capabilities.
Typically, the recruitment analytics journey will go something like this:
1. Descriptive analytics
Description: Focuses on understanding what has happened in the past by summarizing historical data.
Purpose: Provides a retrospective view to understand past recruitment performance and trends.
Example metrics: Number of applications received, time to fill, and source of hire.
2. Diagnostic analytics
Description: Dives deeper into the data to determine why past outcomes occurred by identifying patterns and relationships.
Purpose: Helps in diagnosing issues and understanding the underlying causes of recruitment performance.
Example metrics: Analyzing reasons for high time-to-hire in specific departments or understanding drop-off points in the hiring process.
3. Predictive analytics
Description: Uses statistical models and machine learning algorithms to forecast future outcomes based on historical data.
Purpose: Enables proactive decision-making by anticipating future recruitment challenges and opportunities.
Example Metrics: Predicting which candidates are likely to accept job offers, forecasting future hiring needs.
4. Prescriptive analytics
Description: Provides recommendations and courses of action to achieve desired outcomes by using optimization and simulation models.
Purpose: Guides decision-makers in implementing actions that can improve recruitment efficiency and effectiveness.
Example metrics: Suggestions for optimizing job postings for better candidate engagement or recommending sourcing strategies to improve the quality of hire.
5. Cognitive analytics
Description: Utilizes artificial intelligence (AI) and natural language processing (NLP) to understand and interact with human language and unstructured data.
Purpose: Enhances the recruitment process by automating complex tasks and providing deeper insights from unstructured data sources.
Example Metrics: Automated resume screening and sentiment analysis of candidate feedback.
Summary of levels
- Descriptive Analytics: What happened? (Basic reporting)
- Diagnostic Analytics: Why did it happen? (Identifying patterns and causes)
- Predictive Analytics: What will happen? (Forecasting future trends)
- Prescriptive Analytics: What should we do? (Recommending actions)
- Cognitive Analytics: How can AI enhance recruitment? (Leveraging AI and NLP)
Recruitment Analytics Best Practices
Here are some best practices to effectively leverage recruitment analytics to enhance your hiring processes, make data-driven decisions, and continuously your talent acquisition strategies.
1. Set clear recruitment goals
As Mariya Hristova highlights in her excellent article on recruitment metrics, “It’s rare that you’ll have the capacity to actively keep track of everything.”
So, to help focus, a first step is ensuring that recruitment goals are aligned with the overall business objectives and workforce planning needs.
For instance, if an organizational goal is to rapidly develop a new product line, recruitment’s main goal should be to quickly hire talent with the relevant skills and experience.
In turn, this will help recruiting teams calibrate recruitment analytics and reporting more effectively.
2. Develop clear metrics
A lot of people get confused between the Time to Fill and Time to Hire metrics. Technically speaking, Time to Fill is the period between you opening a position and hiring someone, while Time to Hire is the time it took for the specific candidate you hired to move from application to hire.
This demonstrates the need to always clearly define metrics, as well as how it’s calculated and what your data sources are.
3. Use different types of data
I touched on this above but wanted to reiterate. Most of the data you’ll be using is quantitative, meaning it can be represented numerically.
However, don’t neglect qualitative data such as feedback from candidates or hiring teams. This is just as valuable and can lead to improvements that benefit retention such as improved total compensation.
As Sarah Lovelace, VP of People at Airbase, emphasizes, “By approaching talent management with a blend of data and analysis, we can make informed decisions and effectively communicate them to the broader organization.”
4. Present data in a meaningful way
Data visualization is an essential part of data-driven recruiting. When presenting data to drive action, it’s important to think carefully about the data and also the conversation you’re trying to prompt with your audience. This is where using internal personas comes into play.
Personas are used by marketing teams to paint a picture of their target customers when building out marketing campaigns, and they’re a useful tool for data visualization too.
For example, not everyone needs to know everything, and each stakeholder will require different levels of help to analyze what’s being presented to them.
An example might be the difference between the kind of data you’re presenting to a hiring manager to improve a certain aspect of the hiring process vs a member of the C-Suite to get the OK for a new recruiting software tool.
For further guidance here, I highly recommend Liam Reese’s excellent article on HR data analytics.
5. Utilize the right tools
To effectively leverage recruitment analytics, you’re going to need some kind of tool, likely an applicant tracking system (ATS) or standalone recruitment analytics software.
As well as being a central source of recruitment data, ATS features like interactive recruitment dashboards, industry benchmarking, and customizable reports make it easier to monitor key metrics and KPIs continuously.
The more advanced the tool, the more it will be able to help you with the aforementioned predictive, prescriptive, and cognitive analytics.
Of course, you can always manually collate and analyze data in a humble spreadsheet, it will just take more effort.
Join The People Managing People Community
For further guidance on recruitment analytics and other talent management strategies, join our supportive community of HR and business leaders sharing knowledge and expertise to help you grow in your career and make a greater impact in your organization.
