What Is Global Payroll? Complete Guide 2024
Payroll is one of those thankless tasks that receives little attention until it goes wrong.
With the myriad of taxes and regulations to adhere to, payroll processing can be complex when operating locally, let alone when navigating global payroll for international employees.
But don’t fret, you have options. Use this guide to help you understand global payroll and how you can best approach it.
What Is Global Payroll?
Global payroll means managing and processing payroll for employees in multiple international locations. It involves handling various aspects of payroll operations such as calculating total compensation, withholding taxes, and ensuring compliance with the labor and tax laws of each country where workers are based.
Challenges Of Global Payroll
The process of global payroll is complex due to the differing legal, tax, and regulatory requirements across various jurisdictions.
Compliance with local laws
As mentioned above, each country and jurisdiction has its own tax and labor laws to keep track of. Compliance with these requires ongoing monitoring and swift adaptation to any changes to avoid legal penalties.
For instance, in the USA, payroll must account for federal and state income taxes as well as Social Security and Medicare contributions. The complexity increases because tax rates and rules vary from state to state.
Meanwhile, in the UK, payroll administrators need to ensure compliance with PAYE (Pay As You Earn) tax deductions and National Insurance contributions. Additionally, UK employers must comply with pension auto-enrollment requirements, meaning they need to automatically enroll employees into a pension scheme.
International payments and fees
Handling payroll in multiple currencies can be challenging due to exchange rate fluctuations and banking requirements and fees.
Further, as Wendy Makinson, HR Manager at Joloda Hydroroll, highlights “Some employees around the world still prefer or have to receive their payments in cash and, although this is usually possible when using a global payroll provider, it can incur additional costs.
Time zone differences
Coordinating payroll operations across multiple time zones can complicate communication and workflow, leading to delays and inefficiencies.
Data integration and accuracy
Integrating data from disparate systems and ensuring its accuracy is crucial as errors can lead to incorrect payments and compliance issues.
Data security and privacy concerns
Safeguarding employee data across different regions, each with specific privacy laws (like the Privacy Act of 1974 in the USA and GDPR in Europe), requires robust security and compliance protocols.
Transparency and visibility in payroll data
Transparency and visibility in global payroll is a challenge because payroll data often becomes siloed across different systems and regions, making it difficult to access and consolidate.
This complexity increases as varying local regulations and reporting standards further complicate the retrieval of unified payroll information.
Options For Managing Global Payroll
Organizations can choose from several methods to manage their global payroll needs, each with its own set of advantages and challenges:
In-house global payroll
Some organizations choose to control global payroll processes internally with in-house teams in each country.
This means 1) taking full responsibility for employing and paying global talent, and 2) handling all compliance and administrative tasks.
The advantages are full control and customization of payroll processes tailored to company needs.
However, this method can be costly, time-consuming, and challenging to scale as it requires significant resources for compliance and local expertise in each jurisdiction.
Advantages: Complete control, customization to company needs.
Disadvantages: High cost, time-consuming, hard to scale.
Decentralized global payroll
In a decentralized global payroll model, organizations outsource payroll administration to individual in-country vendors e.g. an employer of record service.
This means 1) working with local third-party payroll providers in each country, and 2) managing multiple vendors across different regions.
While this approach ensures localized compliance and expertise, it also lacks standardization, reduces visibility, and can create security risks when managing multiple systems.
You also relinquish control of the payroll process. As Alice Ferretti, founder of HumansHR, points out “A potential issue with EOR or payroll services is related to the fact that the client has very little to often no control over the individuals that are running payroll and processing payments, compared to having an in-house payroll team.
This means that while working with an EOR allows one to rely on their expertise, there could also be instances when payroll is miscalculated or have issues that impact the clients’ employees but over which the client has little to no control.
I once had a situation where payroll was not submitted on time by the EOR’s payroll specialist, and this caused the employee to miss the window to be paid till the following month.
This took a few days, many phone calls, and, eventually, the need to escalate the issue before it got resolved.
The employee ended up being paid 20 days late and, because this was their first paycheck with us, it had big implications on our ability to build a relationship with them.
It worked out in the end, but the inability we (as the client) had to troubleshoot the issue and resolve it with urgency was very stressful.”
Advantages: Local compliance expertise, easy to scale, adaptability to local needs.
Disadvantages: Managing multiple vendors, lack of standardization, security risks, loss of control.
Centralized global payroll
Some companies choose to streamline global payroll by using one global payroll provider that partners with in-country payroll vendors.
This means 1) consolidating all payroll processes into a single system, and 2) relying on one provider to coordinate with local payroll vendors on your behalf.
Potential advantages of this approach over multiple EORs include a unified platform housing all the data, standardizing payroll processes across all locations, reducing errors, and ensuring consistent application of policies.
However, it is crucial for organizations to carefully vet potential providers to ensure reliability and trustworthiness. As with the decentralized option, you’re still relinquishing control of your payroll process.
Advantages: Streamlined processes, reduced errors, improved visibility.
Disadvantages: Dependency on a single provider, requires thorough vetting of provider reliability.
Use contractors
Of course, another option is to hire contractors who are, in theory, simpler to employ.
One thing to be mindful of here is that, if local authorities legally classify your contractor as an employee, your company is liable for unpaid taxes, back pay, and benefits, and you could also get additional fines.
Advantages: Simple and easy.
Disadvantages: Still have to factor in some local laws and regulations e.g. employee misclassification.
How To Choose The Right Solution
Choosing between processing global payroll in-house vs outsourcing to either local vendors or a global payroll service depends on several factors related to your business needs, resources, and strategic goals.
Here’s a step-by-step process to help you make a decision:
1. Assess your business needs and goals
Geographical presence: Consider the countries where you currently have employees and where you plan to expand. The legal and administrative challenges vary by country.
Employee count: Determine how many employees you have internationally and the projected growth in these numbers.
Core business focus: Evaluate whether managing payroll internally would distract from your core business activities.
2. Evaluate your current resources
Expertise: Do you have, or can you reasonably acquire, the necessary expertise in international labor laws, tax regulations, and payroll processing?
Technology: Assess whether you have the technology to manage payroll efficiently across different countries, including compliance updates and integration with other systems.
Budget: Consider the financial implications, including the cost of setting up and maintaining an in-house process versus the fees for outsourcing.
3. Analyze the pros and cons
Control and customization: In-house processing gives you more control (mistakes are on you and can be rectified by you) and potentially more customization options, which is valuable if you have complex payroll needs.
Scalability: Outsourcing to an EOR or payroll service will help you scale more easily because you don’t have to set up a legal entity in a new market.
Risk management: Outsourcing can reduce the risk of non-compliance and the burden of legal penalties.
5. Long-term strategic fit
Long-term cost: While outsourcing might seem cheaper upfront, it may end up being more expensive in the long run.
As Ferretti highlights “Global providers and EORs can become more expensive if the international team expands, especially if the team expands within the same location.
For example, a team of 100 people across 30 different countries, with an average of 3 to 4 employees in each country, will greatly benefit from an EOR because it would be too expensive and time-consuming to set up the internal capacity to hire and run payroll in-house.
On the other hand, if a company has 100 people across 5 countries with an average of 10-20 people per country, then it could be more cost-effective to build an international HR team in-house.
This varies from company to company and from country to country, but in general, the more employees you have in the same location, the less cost-effective an EOR becomes.”
Business strategy: Align your choice with your overall business strategy. For example, if rapid international expansion is a goal, outsourcing might provide the agility you need.
6. Request proposals and conduct due diligence
Gather proposals: Request detailed proposals from several EOR and global payroll service providers. Some things to look out for besides cost, reputation, and partner-dependent vs owned-entity.
- Local expertise
- Transparent pricing
- Accurate employer burden calculations
- Customer support levels
- Long-term scalability
- Partner-dependent vs owned entity providers (latter is recommended).
- Partner-dependent services rely on local partners in each country to handle employment and payroll, acting as intermediaries.
- Owned-entity EORs have established a legal entity in the countries they operate to directly manage employees and payroll processes.
Check references and reviews: Speak with current and former clients to understand their experiences. Online reviews and testimonials can also provide insights.
7. Make a decision
Make a decision based on your business’s capacity to manage payroll internally without compromising compliance and operational efficiency, and how well each option supports your long-term business objectives.
Global Payroll Best Practices
If you decide to go it alone and handle global payroll in-house, here are some best practices to help guide you:
1. Standardize where possible
Aim to standardize processes across different countries to reduce complexity and increase efficiency. However, also allow for local customization where necessary to meet specific legal and cultural requirements.
2. Stay updated on local laws
Continuously check your knowledge of local employment laws, tax regulations, and reporting requirements in each country. This may involve regular training for your payroll team or consultations with local experts.
3. Leverage technology
Use specialized payroll software that can handle multiple currencies, languages, and regulatory environments. As always, ensure your provider is scalable and can integrate with other HR software and accounting systems.
4. Ensure data security and privacy
Implement robust data protection measures to secure sensitive employee information. This includes following international data protection laws such as GDPR in Europe and similar regulations in other regions.
5. Regular audits and reconciliations
Regardless of whether payroll is international or not, it’s good practice to conduct regular audits of your payroll processes to ensure accuracy and compliance. This helps identify and rectify discrepancies early and maintains the integrity of your payroll system.
6. Effective communication
Maintain clear and open communication channels with your employees regarding payroll matters. This includes providing detailed payslips, explaining any deductions clearly, and being responsive to payroll queries.
7. Centralized reporting
Develop a centralized reporting system that provides visibility into payroll operations across all countries. This aids in strategic decision-making and ensures consistency in reporting standards.
8. Train your team
Invest in continuous training for your payroll team to keep them updated on the latest payroll technologies, regulatory changes, and best practices. Consider payroll certifications that cover global payroll management.
9. Plan for contingencies
Establish contingency plans for payroll processing to handle unexpected situations such as technological failures, data breaches, or sudden changes in legislation.
10. Seek employee feedback
Regularly gather feedback from employees about the payroll process and address any issues or concerns promptly. This can help improve the system and increase employee satisfaction.
Global Payroll Costs
To help you consider the costs associated with a global payroll solution, we've broken them down in a table with estimates around what each one could set you back in USD.
| Category | Cost Type | Details | Estimated Cost |
| Software | Software and infrastructure | Initial costs for multi-country payroll software and necessary IT infrastructure. | $50,000 - $200,000 |
| Software | Integration costs | Costs for integrating payroll system with HR and accounting software | $10,000 - $50,000 |
| Operational | Salaries for payroll staff | Wages for payroll specialists familiar with international regulations. | $60,000 - $120,000 per year |
| Operational | Training costs | Costs for regular training to stay updated on technologies and legislative changes. | $5,000 - $20,000 per year |
| Compliance and Regulatory | Legal and Consulting fees | Fees for legal experts or consultants to ensure compliance and navigate bureaucratic processes. | $20,000 - $100,000 per year |
| Compliance and Regulatory | Audit fees | Costs for conducting regular audits for accuracy and compliance. | $10,000 - $30,000 per year |
| Outsourcing | Service provider fees | Fees for global payroll providers, varying by employee count, countries, and service complexity. | $15 - $50 per employee per month |
| Currency Exchange & Transaction | Currency conversion | Costs for converting currencies for international payroll disbursements. | 0.5% - 2% of transaction amount |
| Currency Exchange & Transaction | Bank fees | Bank transaction fees for international transfers and payments. | $10 - $50 per transaction |
| Error Rectification and Penalties | Error correction | Costs to correct payroll errors, including back payments and interest. | $5,000 - $20,000 per incident |
| Error Rectification and Penalties | Penalties for non-compliance | Fines and penalties for non-compliance with payroll-related laws. | $10,000 - $50,000 per incident |
| Miscellaneous Costs | Project management | Project management costs for implementing new systems or changing providers. | $10,000 - $40,000 per project |
Subscribe To The People Managing People Newsletter
For more advice on managing global payroll and remote workforces, subscribe to our weekly newsletter for HR and business leaders. You’ll receive all our latest content to help you grow in your career and make greater impact in your organization.
